research-document RR-VE-THM-2026-F4B2

Theme Perception Experiment Matrix

Theme Perception Experiment Matrix

Status: active Related: #13

Goal

Turn the theme catalog into a reusable perceptual evidence set, not a palette gallery.

Independent outcomes

Never combine these into one "quality" score:

  1. readability/discriminability
  2. figure-ground salience
  3. visual hierarchy
  4. pair/palette harmony
  5. aesthetic preference
  6. activation association
  7. valence association
  8. semantic/status discrimination
  9. visual fatigue/attention competition
  10. context fit

Current matrix

Theme Experimental dimension
THM-0001 Quiet Fjord light + cool + restrained
THM-0002 Ember Paper light + warm + energetic
THM-0003 Night Ember dark + warm + salient accent
THM-0004 Deep Current dark + cool
THM-0005 Heather Field near-hue / muted harmony
THM-0006 Signal Neutral achromatic + single accent control
THM-0007 Verdant Signal green / natural cool
THM-0008 Cobalt Citrus blue-orange dual accent
THM-0009 Plum Gold dark purple-gold association
THM-0010 Mono Graphite achromatic control
THM-0011 Coral Tide warm-cool complementary candidate
THM-0012 Electric Night dark + multiple high-chroma accents

Evaluation gates

Gate 1 — computed

  • semantic text contrast
  • non-text boundary contrast
  • lightness range
  • chroma range
  • hue separation
  • duplicate/near-duplicate distance

Gate 2 — rendered specimen

Render identical reference surfaces for every theme:

  • prose + headings + links
  • primary/secondary/destructive actions
  • form controls, focus, disabled
  • cards and elevation
  • table
  • status messages
  • small data visualization
  • dense dashboard
  • print/document sample when applicable

Gate 3 — perceptual review

Record outcomes independently:

  • hierarchy clarity
  • foreground salience
  • harmony
  • attentional competition
  • semantic confusion
  • fatigue concerns

Gate 4 — contextual evidence

Where a theme is intended for a real product/context, record target population and task. Do not generalize a contextual result to all applications.

Pairwise experiments

Prefer controlled pairs that alter one dimension:

  • warm vs cool with similar lightness/chroma
  • high vs low chroma with similar hue/lightness
  • light vs dark mode using comparable semantic relationships
  • analogous vs separated hue while holding lightness contrast
  • one accent vs two competing accents
  • subtle vs functional 3:1 boundaries
  • chromatic vs achromatic control

Status policy

  • draft: hypothesis only
  • evaluated: computed checks plus rendered review complete
  • accepted: useful for a stated context with evidence
  • deprecated: retained for history but no longer recommended for that context

Acceptance is contextual. There is no globally "best" theme.

Next expansion

After THM-0012, prioritize:

  • controlled one-variable variants of existing themes
  • status palettes for success/warning/error/info
  • color-vision-deficiency robustness
  • data-series palettes
  • print mappings
  • reduced-chroma/fatigue variants
  • high-contrast functional boundary variants

Do not add more decorative combinations until these controlled variants begin producing comparative evidence.